The Bucknellian

Check out our new and improved website at ww.bucknellian.net!

  • Home
  • About
    • Archives
    • Graduates/Achievements
      • Awards
    • Newsstand Locations
    • PDF Issues
    • Policies
    • Fall 2013 Staff
      • About the Adviser
  • Contact
    • To advertise
    • To join the staff
    • To submit a Letter to the Editor
  • Subscribe
  • Media
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
  • News
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Letters to the Editor
  • Sports
    • Beyond the Bison
    • Club/Intramural
      • Men’s Rowing
      • Men’s Rugby
      • Women’s Rugby
      • Ski Team
      • Men’s Squash
      • Women’s Squash
      • Men’s Volleyball
    • Men
      • Baseball
      • Basketball
      • Cross Country
      • Football
      • Golf
      • Lacrosse
      • Soccer
      • Swimming & Diving
      • Tennis
      • Track & Field
      • Water Polo
    • Women
      • Basketball
      • Cross Country
      • Field Hockey
      • Golf
      • Lacrosse
      • Rowing
      • Soccer
      • Softball
      • Swimming & Diving
      • Tennis
      • Track & Field
      • Volleyball
      • Water Polo
  • Arts & Life
    • Columns
      • Cooking Corner
      • Humor
        • Rees’ Pieces
        • From the Mind of Wiley Jack
      • Off the Beat and Path
      • Sleeping Around
    • Review
      • Books
      • Campus Events
      • Movies
      • Music
      • Restaurants
      • Television
    • Study Abroad

Editorial

September 22, 2010 by Tracy Lum

Students’ behavior at the Howard Gardner lecture last Thursday evening prompted a debate about proper decorum that shouldn’t be necessary on a campus like ours, where maturity is an unstated expectation. The event, however, does raise important questions about the Transition to College course and student engagement at the University.

The fact that first-year students were required to attend the lecture as part of their Transition to College course does not excuse disrespectful or rude behavior. Texting, sleeping and chatting during the presentation reflects poorly on the University as a whole and is a juvenile way of expressing displeasure. Having scholars visit our campus and sharing their ideas is a privilege that we liberal arts students should relish.

As college students, we should be held responsible for our actions, and we should promote change through alternative means, such as well-reasoned argument.

Of course, students are not the only ones at fault. Many students were not engaged in the lecture, perhaps because of the book selection for the first-years’ common reading. Some students believe Gardner’s book, “Five Minds for the Future,” was too light and fluffy, politically correct and even arrogant. Much of the class of 2014 agreed that they hated the book before they even arrived on campus. Still others said Gardner was dismissive of questions and did not handle criticism well. In the future, a book should be chosen that engages students and stimulates intellectual debates.

The Transition to College course itself could also be at fault. Many first-year students do not take this pass-fail course seriously, and this disdainful attitude could have carried over to the lecture. The course, we believe, is valuable to the first-years’ development and adjustment to college life; however, it needs to be presented in a way that will be taken seriously. Perhaps the course could be administered online over the summer, or the information could be conveyed through foundation seminars or interaction with resident assistants. Still, acting out during the speaker’s presentation is a poorly executed way of expressing dissatisfaction with the course.

More generally, we fear the students’ behavior is indicative of a decline in student engagement. In many classes, especially large lectures, students spend their time texting or surfing sites unrelated to classwork. We question whether this is a matter of teaching students how to behave in a college environment, or if it simply speaks to a growing trend of disrespect and apathy in an increasingly mobile and networked age.

Regardless of the causes of students’ poor decorum in presentation spaces and in the classroom, we strongly urge University students to think deeply about why they are in college and about how they comport themselves. If they are here to truly learn and broaden their minds, we hope they will show it by putting down their mobile devices, staying awake during lectures, paying attention in class and acting like mature and engaged college students.

Filed Under: Editorial, Opinion Tagged With: Howard Gardner, lecture, student behavior

Recent Comments

  • Jennifer on Editorial: House Party excess is a community wide issue
  • Francisca B. Barry on “Breaking Bad” leaves audience in anticipation
  • Lance McDonald on Hip-hop artist storms off Spring Concert stage early in setlist
  • Give Credit Where Credit Is Due on To submit a Letter to the Editor
  • Melissa on Fall 2013 Staff

Like us on Facebook

Check out our Twitter

Check out our Instagram

Tags

Athlete of the week athlete of the year baseball BSG Bucknell Forum Bucknellian sports awards comedy comprehensive fee Cooking Corner Egypt field hockey football golf harry potter Hotel Rwanda Howard Gardner lecture men's basketball men's golf men's lacrosse men's soccer men's tennis men's track men's water polo NIT Paul Rusesabagina People of the Year pool pass project review senior reflections softball student behavior The Buried life volleyball Wiley Jack women's basketball women's golf women's lacrosse women's rowing women's soccer women's swimming women's tennis women's track women's water polo wrestling

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Copyright © 2023 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in